Altered Kirkus Review

 

On October 10, 2017, Kirkus Reviews issued the following review of American Heart. The review had a star, which Kirkus describes as denoting “exceptional merit.”

Fifteen-year-old Sarah Mary will do anything for her sensitive younger brother, but she never thought that would mean running from the law.


The setting is the Midwestern United States; the time is the not-too-distant future. A Muslim registry is in effect, and Muslims are being bused to detention centers called "safety zones" en masse. This doesn't bother Sarah Mary, a strong-minded, fiercely loyal, and protective teenager whose mother has abandoned her and her younger brother, Caleb, to their ultraconservative Christian aunt. (The whole family appears to be white.) Her indifference is forced to change when Caleb's compassion for Sadaf, a Muslim in hiding, gets her involved in a plan to help this Iranian woman escape. Together, Sarah Mary and her new companion face extreme dangers, prejudices, disappointments—and unexpected kindnesses from their fellow Americans as they fight nearly impossible odds to get Sadaf through several states and over the border undetected. Moriarty creates a frighteningly believable setting of fear and violent nativism gone awry as she traces their journey to help Sadaf find the freedom she sought when she immigrated to the United States. By turns terrifying, suspenseful, thought-provoking, and touching, this book is so rich that the coincidences in the plot are easily forgiven.


A moving portrait of an American girl discovering her society in crisis, desperate to show a disillusioned immigrant the true spirit of America. (Fiction. 13-18)

 

The following message from Kirkus appeared on October 14, after the original review was taken down:

A NOTE FROM THE EDITOR IN CHIEF

It is a policy of Kirkus Reviews that books with diverse subject matter and protagonists are assigned to Own Voices reviewers—writers who can draw upon lived experience when evaluating texts. Our assignment of the review of American Heart was no exception to this rule and was reviewed by an observant Muslim person of color (facts shared with her permission). Our reviewer is an expert in children’s & YA literature and well-versed in the dangers of white savior narratives. She found that American Heart offers a useful warning about the direction we’re headed in as far as racial enmity is concerned.

The issue of diversity in children’s and teen literature is of paramount importance to Kirkus, and we appreciate the power language wields in discussion of the problems. As a result, we've removed the starred review from kirkus.com after determining that, while we believe our reviewer’s opinion is worthy and valid, some of the wording fell short of meeting our standards for clarity and sensitivity, and we failed to make the thoughtful edits our readers deserve. The editors are evaluating the review and will make a determination about correction or retraction after careful consideration in collaboration with the reviewer.

At Kirkus Reviews, we will continue to evaluate editorial solutions for better reflecting the expertise of our reviewers and their uniform appreciation for responsible portrayals of marginalized groups. We appreciate the discussion of these issues and celebrate the free exchange of opinions and ideas.

 
 

For further reading:

YA Novel About “Mob Mentalities” Punished After Online Backlash

October 16, 2017

This article, by Ruth Graham, provides an overview of the situation.

Kirkus Editor-in-Chief Explains Why They Altered That American Heart Review

October 19, 2017

This article, by Kat Rosenfield, features an interview with the editor-in-chief of Kirkus.

The Problem with ‘Problematic’

November 1, 2017

Francine Prose weighs in with a thoughtful essay.

The Toxic Drama on YA Twitter

August 7, 2017

This earlier article by Kat Rosenfield provides an overview of the current YA climate.

YA Twitter’s Diversity War Is Hurting Writers Of Color

October 19, 2017

This article, by Ryan Douglass, explores some of the further consequences of callout culture.

 

©2017 by Laura Moriarty